CRR Reports on the Improvement in the Funded Status of Public Plans

Industry News

Print

CRR Reports on the Improvement in the Funded Status of Public Plans

On July 22, 2025, the Center for Retirement Research (CRR) at Boston College released its issue brief, The Funded Status of Public Plans Keeps Improving – Albeit Modestly. According to the report, the state and local pension funding ratio is projected to have increased to 77.7% in fiscal year 2025, up 1.5% over the last two years.

Other key findings include:

  • The increase in the funded ratio indicates growth in assets from higher contributions and favorable returns as well as the realization of benefit reductions scheduled for new employees.
  • The impact of these improvements is partially offset by: 1) negative cash flows in maturing pension plans; and 2) growth in benefit liabilities.

The report concludes, “The gradual improvement in the funded status of state and local pensions reflects gains in the fundamentals. These gains include more stringent calculations of actuarially required contributions and the increased likelihood of actually making the payment, as well as the ongoing effect of benefit cuts introduced after the Great Recession and the implementation of further cuts as new hires replace old employees. But, even if governments continue to contribute the full actuarially required contribution and investment performance remains mostly positive, we should only anticipate incremental improvements in funded ratios due to two persistent features of pension funds – the annual growth of liabilities and the impact of negative cash flows, associated with mature plans, on accumulated assets.”

The brief is available here.

NCPERS Reports Public Pensions Drive $2.9 Trillion in Economic Output

Industry News

Print

NCPERS Reports Public Pensions Drive $2.9 Trillion in Economic Output

On July 16, 2025, the National Conference of Public Employee Retirement Systems (NCPERS) released its report, the Unintended Consequences: How Scaling Back Public Pensions Puts Government Revenues at Risk. The report provides a comprehensive analysis of state and local revenues generated from retiree spending of pension benefits and the investment of pension assets to taxpayer contributions for public pensions. The 2025 report updates the original report published in 2018 and subsequent 2020 edition. 

The study analyzed how investment and spending related to public pension funds affect state and local economies and revenues. According to the report, public pension funds had a positive financial impact on the U.S. economy contributing $2.9 trillion in 2023 with $1.9 trillion from the investment of pension fund assets and $980.7 billion from retiree spending of pension checks.   

Some of the other key findings include:

  • Economic growth attributable to public pensions generated about $661.9 billion in state and local tax revenues. After taking taxpayer contributions into account of $216.7 billion, the net positive revenue impact was $445.2 billion.
  • The trend in net revenue gain from public pensions has grown steadily from 2016 in 43 states.
  • In 2023, every dollar that taxpayers contributed to public pensions generated $13.41 in economic activity.

Before considering reforms, the findings indicate that policymakers should evaluate the economic impact of public pensions holistically. In the short term, reducing benefits or closing pension plans may seem to save money, but the long-term costs may reduce economic activity and public services, increase taxpayer burdens, and reduce retirement security for public servants.

The report concludes, “Going forward, efforts to preserve and strengthen public pensions should be paired with a broader reassessment of state and local revenue systems. This includes identifying ways to ensure tax structures reflect modern economic realities and considering areas where tax benefits or exemptions may be eroding the revenue base. In this context, thoughtful, evidence-based policy decisions are essential to maintaining the long-term sustainability and benefits of public pensions.”

The analysis was based on historical state-level data from public sources including the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA), Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) and U.S. Census Bureau. 

The report is available here.

NASRA Reports on Sustainability Provisions for Public Pension Plans with Fixed Employer Contributions

Industry News

Print

NASRA Reports on Sustainability Provisions for Public Pension Plans with Fixed Employer Contributions

On July 8, 2025, the National Association of State Retirement Administrators (NASRA) released their report, Sustainability Provisions for Public Pension Plans with Fixed Employer Contributions. NASRA explored various approaches that some plans use to balance the adequacy and stability of employer contributions.

According to NASRA, “Most public pension plan contribution policies are set in statute and fall into one of two broad types: variable or fixed rate. Under variable rate policies, the employer’s contribution rate generally fluctuates with the actuarially determined contribution rate, which changes based on the plan’s actuarial experience. As the name suggests, fixed-rate policies feature an employer contribution that is fixed in statute as a percentage of payroll. This rate is stable and changes rarely or incrementally, typically through legislation or in some cases, automatic adjustment provision.”

In some cases, “to address plan sustainability in the context of fixed contribution rates, many such plans must adopt mechanisms that result in the adjustment of contributions or, in certain circumstances, benefits, to help maintain plan sustainability. So, in another sense, a third category of funding approach – neither variable (actuarially-based) or fixed, but rather, specific (stated in law, but adjustable at certain times and to certain extents) – may be required to accurately characterize some public pension plans.”

Some of the key findings include:

  • Depending on actuarial experience, fixed employer contribution rates provide budget stability for employers, but may result in funding shortfalls.
  • Many plans referred to as “fixed-rate plans” use various strategies to maintain actuarial balance, such as benefit modifications, statutory adjustments or supplemental funding sources.
  • Some plans display various characteristics of both fixed and variable contribution policies, which may demonstrate the need for adaptable funding strategies.  

The report concludes, “Although a variable-rate approach is designed to ensure that contributions adjust to maintain actuarial balance, it can also create budget uncertainty for employers. Fixed-rate policies, on the other hand, offer stability but may lead to funding shortfalls or surpluses depending on economic and demographic conditions or changes in actuarial methods and assumptions. The sustainability of fixed rate plans in many cases depends on mechanisms such as funding adequacy assessments, statutory flexibility, and supplemental revenue sources to promote actuarial balance. As demonstrated by the practices of several public pension plans, the distinction between fixed and variable funding approaches is increasingly blurred, with many so-called fixed-rate plans incorporating elements of flexibility to ensure long-term financial stability. Ultimately, the effectiveness of any pension funding policy depends on its ability to adequately fund the plan’s long-term liabilities.”

In addition, the report includes an appendix with selected examples of sustainability provisions for public pension plans with specific employer contribution rates that differ in their approach, scope and magnitude.

The report is available here.

CRR Publishes Brief on the Financial Outlook of Social Security in 2025

Industry News

Print

CRR Publishes Brief on the Financial Outlook of Social Security in 2025

On July 8, 2025, the Center for Retirement Research (CRR) at Boston College released its issue brief, Social Security’s Financial Outlook: The 2025 Update in Perspective. As presented in the issue brief, CRR analyzed the 75-year deficit in Social Security benefits projected in the recently released 2025 Social Security Board of Trustees Report.  

The key findings include: 

  • The 2025 Trustees Report indicated that the 75-year deficit increased from 3.50% to 3.82% of taxable payrolls, and the trust fund’s depletion date remains at 2033.
  • The future deficit could be higher if the fertility rate remains low, millions of immigrants are deported and future immigration levels are reduced, and people live longer than expected.
  • The projected depletion date for the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) trust fund assets remains at 2033.
  • A lower assumed disability incidence rate allows the Disability Insurance (DI) trust fund to pay full benefits for the next 75 years.
  • The depletion date for the combined OASDI trust funds is 2034 (one year earlier than last year’s report).

Notably, the change in the deficit is somewhat higher than last year’s report mainly due to: 1) the enactment of the Social Security Fairness Act that raised the benefits for some state and local workers; 2) the period of recovery from current low fertility rates that was extended by 10 years to 2050; 3) the projection period that was moved forward one year, which replaces a low-deficit year with a high-deficit year; and 4) the projected ratio of labor compensation to GDP that was reduced, which reduces payroll tax revenues. 

The brief concludes, “Social Security is facing a long-term financing shortfall that equals about 1 percent of GDP. The changes required to fix the system are well within the bounds of fluctuations in spending on other pro­grams in the past. Moreover, action needs to be taken before the OASI trust fund is depleted in 2033 to avoid a precipitous cut in benefits.” 

The brief is available here. 

Groom Law Group Summarizes Benefits-Related Provisions Enacted in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act

Industry News

Print

Groom Law Group Summarizes Benefits-Related Provisions Enacted in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act

On July 3, 2025, the Groom Law Group released its publication, One Big Beautiful Bill: The Benefits Provisions. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA) was signed into law on July 4, 2025. In this publication, the Groom Law Group provides a chart that summarizes the House and Senate proposals as well as the OBBBA final provisions and effective dates.

The budget reconciliation package included tax incentives related to paid family leave, employer-provided child care, telehealth services and education benefits, among others. Several tax credits that were temporary under the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 are now permanent, which generally may result in more employers offering benefits related to those tax credits.

There were numerous benefits-related provisions included in the final version. Notably, the new law does not change the tax incentives for retirement savings or cap the exclusion for employer-sponsored health insurance. However, it does include other benefit-related provisions, such as changes to Health Savings Accounts (HSAs), High-Deductible Health Plans (HDHPs), fringe benefits, education expenses, compensation-related provisions in the form of tips and overtime wages, and executive compensation. In addition, the Act creates new tax-preferred “Trump Accounts” for children and provides the Office of Management and Budget with $100 million for deregulatory activities.

The chart is available here.

Moody’s Finds Public Pension Liabilities Declined in FY 25 for the Fifth Consecutive Year

Industry News

Print

Moody's Finds Public Pension Liabilities Declined in FY 25 for the Fifth Consecutive Year

On July 1, 2025, Moody’s Ratings reported that state and local governments’ Adjusted Net Pension Liabilities (ANPLs) decreased for the fifth consecutive fiscal year. As of June 30, 2025, their ANPLs were about $2.1 trillion, down by a cumulative $4 trillion since fiscal year 2020. This decline was mainly due to higher market interest rates.

In addition, Moody’s estimated that U.S. public pension systems have earned about 10% to 11% for fiscal year ending June 30, 2025. Generally, those systems have posted returns near or above their annual targets that ranged from 6.75% to 7.25% for three consecutive fiscal years.

Moody’s indicated that another year of decline in ANPLs would continue to lower state and local governments’ balance sheet leverage, which would positively affect their credit quality. However, it also cautions that this trend could be reversed by investment losses or interest rate reductions.

​The report is available here.

NASBO Releases Spring 2025 Fiscal Survey of States

Industry News

Print

NASBO Releases Spring 2025 Fiscal Survey of States

Recently, the National Association of State Budget Officers (NASBO) released their semi-annual report, The Fiscal Survey of States: Spring 2025. The report updates information on the states’ fiscal conditions and presents aggregate and individual data on the states’ general fund receipts, expenditures and balances. The survey was conducted by NASBO and completed by the governors’ state budget officers in all 50 states.   

The report highlights governors’ budget proposals for fiscal 2026 and provides updated estimates for general fund spending, revenue and balances for fiscal 2025 as well as actual data for fiscal 2024. According to NASBO, in fiscal 2026, general fund ending balances are expected to continue declining for the third consecutive year, but are projected to remain elevated compared to historical levels.

For fiscal 2026, the recommended budgets are estimated to increase by 0.8% for general fund spending. In fiscal 2026, 24 states are projecting lower general fund spending in recommended budgets compared to fiscal 2025 levels and the reported median annual growth rate is 0.0%. In fiscal 2025, states estimated total general fund spending of $1.30 trillion, up 5.1% from fiscal 2024.

Other key findings include: 

  • For fiscal 2025 general fund revenue collections, 34 states reported exceeding original budgeted revenue projections, while nine states reported being on target to original estimates and seven reported being below estimates.
  • For fiscal 2026, revenue projections are 2.8% higher than current estimates for fiscal 2025, which would mark a fourth consecutive year of modest revenue growth.
  • For fiscal 2026, governors’ budgets propose a combination of tax policy changes with 14 states recommending net increases and 20 states recommending net decreases.
  • As a share of general fund spending, the median rainy day fund balance is expected to be maintained or increase although the balance as a percentage of expenditures declined in fiscal 2025 due to general fund spending increasing faster than reserves in the same year. The median rainy day fund balance is projected to decline from an all-time high of 14.6% in fiscal 2024 to 12.8% in fiscal 2025 and slightly increase to 12.9% in fiscal 2026.
  • Total balances that include rainy day funds and general fund ending balances represented 31.1% as a share of total general fund expenditures at the end of fiscal 2024; as states draw down general fund balances, total balances are projected to be 25.2% of general fund expenditures in fiscal 2025 and 21.9% in fiscal 2026.  

The full report and summary are available here.