NASRA Updates Issue Brief on State Hybrid Retirement Plans

Industry News

Print

NASRA Updates Issue Brief on State Hybrid Retirement Plans

On September 24, 2024, the National Association of State Retirement Administrators (NASRA) released its issue brief, State Hybrid Retirement Plans, which updates an earlier version published in September 2023. The brief provides new information on statewide cash balance and combination hybrid plans as well as a map that illustrates the percentage of public employees who participate in mandatory or optional hybrid plans in states that administer such plans for groups of general, public safety or K-12 educational employees.    

While the majority of public employee retirement systems are traditional defined benefit plans, some public sector plans are considering hybrid plans that contain elements of both defined benefit (DB) and defined contribution (DC) plans. The brief examines two types of hybrid plans: 1) cash balance plans that combine elements of a traditional DB plan and individual accounts into a single plan; and 2) “DB+DC” plans that combine a smaller traditional DB pension plan with separate individual DC retirement savings accounts.     

The brief also provides overviews of cash balance and DB+DC plans that have been established in various states, with some dating back several decades. According to the brief, public sector hybrid plans have diverse combinations of retirement plan designs to address the cost and risk factors of various state or local governments. However, most continue to include features that meet fundamental retirement plan objectives including: mandatory participation, shared financing, professionally managed pooled investments, benefit adequacy and lifetime benefit payouts. Typically, traditional public sector DB plans that contain hybrid plan elements include benefits or employee contributions that are linked to the plan’s investment performance or actuarial condition. 

The brief also contains an appendix providing detailed information by individual retirement plans of: 1) an overview of cash balance hybrid plans; 2) basic DB+DC hybrid plans facts; and 3) DB and DC component features.

The brief is available here. 

 

CRR Releases Issue Brief on the Role of State Governments on Funding Teacher Pensions

Industry News

Print

CRR Releases Issue Brief on the Role of State Governments on Funding Teacher Pensions

On September 24, 2024, the Center for Retirement Research (CRR) at Boston College released its issue brief, What Role Does State Government Play in Funding Teacher Pensions? CRR examined the role of state governments in funding teacher retirement benefits. According to CRR, “[A]bout two-thirds of states explicitly provide funds for teacher pensions, with 15 of these states paying the full cost on behalf of schools. The remaining third of states implicitly help with pensions through basic state aid to schools, but this aid seems to have fallen somewhat behind rising costs.”  

Specifically, 35 states (including Washington, D.C.) explicitly provide funds for some portion of teachers’ retirement benefits as of June 2024. The CRR findings indicate that 15 states (with 15 plans) explicitly fund all teacher pension costs and 20 states (with 24 plans) provide funds for a portion of the costs.

Since 2001, CRR reported that teacher pension costs have doubled as a share of payroll, up from about 8% to nearly 20% in 2024. It indicated that a significant portion of expenditures for school districts are related to personnel costs. Overall, school districts rely greatly on support from state government transfers for revenue.

According to the brief, 38% of state governments cover all of the annual required contribution (ARC) of teacher pension plans. In states that do not pay the full ARC, about 23% pay a fixed percentage of salary or a fixed dollar amount.

The brief is available here.

American Academy of Actuaries Publishes Brief on Informing Public Pension Plan Participants Taking a Buyout or Other Lump Sums

Industry News

Print

American Academy of Actuaries Publishes Brief on Informing Public Pension Plan Participants Taking a Buyout or Other Lump Sums

On September 11, 2024, the American Academy of Actuaries (AAA) published its issue brief, Public Pension Plans: Helping Members Evaluate Buyout Programs and Other Lump Sums. The brief was authored by the AAA’s Public Plans Committee. It presents information that may help members of public pension plans that are offered buyout programs to compare the value of lifetime benefits to the buyout or other lump sum amounts.

The issue brief suggests that members should always receive an explanation of the buyout calculation which should indicate the present value calculated by the plan and the percentage of the present value used to determine the buyout amount, if applicable. In addition, the brief also suggests that it would be helpful for members to have: 1) an estimate of the cost to replace the benefits that would be payable in the private market; and 2) an estimated annual investment return on the buyout amount required to replace the pension benefits that would be relinquished assuming an average life expectancy.

Some of the key assumption findings include:

  • Higher discount rates produce smaller lump sums;
  • Lower assumed Cost-of-Living Adjustments (COLAs) produce smaller lump sums;
  • Mortality assumptions may significantly affect the amount of the calculated lump sum; and
  • In addition to the other assumptions, most buyout programs apply other factors or adjustments to the lump sum calculation.

Importantly, the Committee cautions that members should consult with a professional fiduciary financial adviser prior to making a significant irrevocable decision for a buyout offer based on their individual circumstances.

Among other members, the AAA’s Public Plans Committee includes Judith Kermans, President, CEO and Senior Consultant at GRS. 

The issue brief is available here.

CRR Issues Brief on Retirement Outlook for Millennials

Industry News

Print

CRR Issues Brief on Retirement Outlook for Millennials

Recently, the Center for Retirement Research (CRR) at Boston College released its issue brief, Is the Retirement Picture for Millennials Looking Better? CRR studied the effects of the global pandemic and economic disruption since 2019 on the retirement preparedness of Millennials (those born during 1981-1999).

In addition, the issue brief indicated that several factors were significantly higher than in 2019 including the unprecedented governmental fiscal support; strong employment rate; significantly increasing home values; and stock market increases (despite the significant drop in 2022).

The key findings include:

  • Initially, Millennials embarked on their work careers in very weak labor markets and, therefore, lagged behind Late Boomers and Gen Xers at the same ages in wealth and life events.
  • However, a significant change was revealed in 2022 that Millennials absorbed most factors and actually surpassed earlier cohorts in wealth growth.
  • This was mainly due to a substantial increase in housing wealth which excelled during COVID and financial wealth gains which also helped to improve balance sheets.
  • The effect on retirement security for Millennials is yet to be determined since housing prices may reverse and typically retirees do not use their home equity for covering their consumption during retirement.

The brief concludes, “Millennials now have more net wealth relative to income in their 30s than Gen Xers and Late Boomers had, despite still having more student debt. Most of the improvement in their balance sheets is due to the rapid increase in housing prices during the pandemic. They also have higher non-housing wealth as well, thanks to increased saving and being positioned to profit from a strong stock market.”

It adds, “Despite all the improvements, the good fortune of the Millennials relies primarily on housing. The house is an illiquid asset, and few people take advantage of their home equity to support their consumption in retirement. Hence, it is not clear the extent to which housing equity should be counted as retirement saving.”

The issue brief is available here.

Interest Rates Have Risen from Historic Lows. Does That Mean We Can Raise Our Assumed Rate of Return?

In this article, we discuss increases in interest rates from historic lows, potential impacts on PERS’ portfolio expectations, and policy issues surrounding changing the assumed rate of return. This article offers public plan stakeholders some considerations about the potential impact of the interest rate increases on the assumed rate of investment return assumption used in actuarial valuations.